The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping arrived in cinemas this week, with its young stars discussing the pressure of joining the blockbuster franchise as Canadian critics question the prequel's relentlessly bleak storytelling. Joseph Zada, Mckenna Grace and Whitney Peak spoke to BBC News about the demanding production and their close bond on set. Meanwhile, a November 20 review from CBC argues that the sixth film works better as an explanation of a familiar character's suffering than as an introduction for newcomers. The contrasting responses have put the spotlight on whether revisiting Haymitch Abernathy's past adds enough to the series.

What Sparked the Controversy
The discussion centres on the creative direction of Sunrise on the Reaping, an adaptation of Suzanne Collins' 2025 novel that explores the experiences of Haymitch Abernathy decades before audiences encountered him in the original films.
Set 24 years before the first Hunger Games movie, the story follows the 50th Hunger Games, also known as the Second Quarter Quell. Zada portrays the younger version of the character previously played by Woody Harrelson, while Grace plays fellow District 12 tribute Maysilee Donner and Peak portrays Haymitch's girlfriend, Lenore Dove.
In his November 20 review for CBC, Toronto-based critic Jackson Weaver argues that the movie places so much emphasis on explaining Haymitch's trauma that it struggles to deliver a satisfying standalone story.
The criticism concerns the film's narrative choices rather than allegations of misconduct or a dispute between cast members. Weaver acknowledges its effectiveness as an entry in the dystopian action genre but questions whether its emotional trajectory offers newcomers enough reason to become invested.
What Is Confirmed
Sunrise on the Reaping is the sixth Hunger Games film, extending a franchise that has generated more than $3.3 billion worldwide since its cinematic debut in 2012, according to the BBC.
Its cast includes Ralph Fiennes as President Snow, Jesse Plemons as a games producer and Glenn Close as a Capitol representative. Maya Hawke, Kieran Culkin and Elle Fanning also feature in the ensemble.
The story returns to Panem, a fictional post-apocalyptic North America divided into districts controlled by the Capitol. The annual Hunger Games force selected young participants into a deadly competition intended as punishment for rebellion.

The new storyline also introduces Beetee Latier, portrayed by Kelvin Harrison Jr., who proposes a plan to undermine the Capitol from within the competition. His proposal creates a conflict between surviving the Games and attempting to challenge the system responsible for them.
Director Francis Lawrence has presented the film as an entry point for viewers unfamiliar with earlier instalments, according to CBC. That ambition provides the central point of disagreement: whether a prequel built around an established character can carry the same emotional weight without knowledge of his eventual future.
- Prequel
- A story set before the events of an earlier released work.
- Tribute
- A participant selected from a district to compete in the Hunger Games.
- Second Quarter Quell
- The special 50th edition of the Hunger Games depicted in this film.
What Each Side Has Said
The cast's comments focus on the emotional and physical demands of filming rather than responding directly to the critical review.
In an interview with BBC News, Grace described joining the franchise as an unusually intimidating experience despite her previous work in The Handmaid's Tale, The Haunting of Hill House and the Ghostbusters films.
I don't think anything can prepare you for working on it - this is nothing like anything I've experienced.
Zada explained that he studied Harrelson's performances for months before developing his own interpretation of Haymitch. He later received advice from Harrelson to watch Cool Hand Luke and Harold and Maud, with the former helping him ground his performance.
Peak described the intensity of production, while Grace emphasized the importance of the relationships formed between cast members. Plemons praised Zada's stamina, and Close also spoke positively about working with the younger actors.
The BBC reports that reviews have generally been positive, including praise for Zada's performance. CBC's criticism is more pointed, arguing that the film's prolonged depiction of suffering makes it particularly difficult for viewers encountering the franchise for the first time.
These assessments are not necessarily contradictory. A performance can be compelling even when a critic finds the surrounding narrative unsatisfying.
What Is Still Unclear
The available reporting does not establish how audiences as a whole are responding to the film. The BBC describes generally positive reviews, while CBC offers a strongly critical assessment of its storytelling. Neither source supplies an opening-weekend box-office total or comprehensive audience survey.
There is also no evidence in the supplied reporting of a public disagreement between the actors and the filmmakers about the movie's direction.
One unresolved critical question is whether viewers already familiar with Haymitch will respond differently from newcomers. CBC argues that knowing his future gives the tragedy greater context, but the available sources do not quantify that difference in audience reaction.
What Happens Next
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is now in cinemas. With its release underway, the film can be judged both as a continuation of the established series and as the independent entry point its director intended.
For Canadian moviegoers, the practical distinction is straightforward: CBC's review recommends beginning with the original Hunger Games rather than this prequel. Viewers already familiar with Haymitch may find greater significance in the events that explain his later behaviour.
The available sources do not confirm a subsequent film announcement, a new release schedule or any planned changes in response to criticism. The immediate story is the contrast between enthusiasm for the performances and disagreement over how the prequel handles its central character.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping out now?
Yes. BBC News reports that Sunrise on the Reaping is currently in cinemas. It is the sixth film in the Hunger Games franchise.
Who plays young Haymitch in Sunrise on the Reaping?
Joseph Zada plays teenage Haymitch Abernathy. Woody Harrelson portrayed the older version of the character in the original films.
What is Sunrise on the Reaping about?
The film follows Haymitch during the 50th Hunger Games, 24 years before the original movie. It explores his participation in the competition and the experiences that shape his later character.
Why are critics divided over the new Hunger Games movie?
The BBC reports generally positive reviews, including praise for Joseph Zada. CBC critic Jackson Weaver argues that the film relies too heavily on Haymitch's suffering and is less effective for newcomers.
Who else stars in Sunrise on the Reaping?
Mckenna Grace plays Maysilee Donner, Whitney Peak portrays Lenore Dove and Ralph Fiennes plays President Snow. The ensemble also includes Glenn Close, Jesse Plemons, Maya Hawke, Kieran Culkin and Elle Fanning.