Scott Lindsey’s first official match in charge of York City ended in a 2-0 defeat to his former club, Crawley Town, as the Minstermen were knocked out of the Carabao Cup in the preliminary round at the LNER Community Stadium.

The Story at a Glance
York City's return to competitive action as an EFL club got off to a difficult start as goals from debutant Gianmarco Di Biase and substitute Danilo Orsi secured passage to the first round for Crawley Town. The defeat was particularly bitter for new head coach Scott Lindsey, who was facing the same Crawley side he managed last season. Frustration among the home crowd was evident toward the closing stages of the match, with chants directed at the club's board following the controversial dismissal of title-winning manager Stuart Maynard on the eve of the campaign.
How the Story Developed
The visitors took the initiative early in the match, with on-loan Fulham goalkeeper Alfie McNally saving a low strike from Malcolm Ebiowei. York created opportunities through Alex Hunt's corner deliveries, as defender Zech Medley saw a low header drift narrowly wide. Crawley opened the scoring in the 24th minute when Kellan Gordon advanced down the right flank and delivered a low cross for Italian winger Gianmarco Di Biase, who tapped the ball into the net to mark his debut following his summer transfer from Juventus.

York pushed for an equalizer in the second half. Dipo Akinyemi saw a close-range header saved by Vito Mannone, while Medley hit the underside of the crossbar with a volley following another Hunt corner. However, Crawley settled the outcome in the 86th minute when defender Zak Johnson committed a handball in the penalty area. Substitute Danilo Orsi converted the resulting penalty, slotting the ball home as McNally dived to his left.
Key People and Details
The match marked the competitive debuts for several York players, including goalkeeper Alfie McNally, defender Zech Medley, and Jack Hunt. Ollie Banks was deployed in a deeper midfield position by Lindsey, who described the shift as tactical flexibility designed to allow Joe Grey to operate in advanced spaces. Crawley, managed by Colin Kazim-Richards, featured standout performances from Charlie Barker and Malcolm Ebiowei, while Di Biase scored on his competitive debut.
A total of 4,788 spectators attended the tie at the LNER Community Stadium, including 192 visiting supporters from Sussex.
Reaction and Response
The home crowd expressed vocal disapproval during the second half, chanting the name of former manager Stuart Maynard, who led York to promotion from the National League with 108 points last season before his dismissal.
Addressing his team selection and Banks's role after the match, head coach Scott Lindsey defended his tactical choices:
I remember Banksy playing for Chesterfield years ago. He was really deep, controlling the game, and I felt that he was close to being our best player tonight.
What to Watch
Crawley Town advance to face Championship side Watford at Vicarage Road in the Carabao Cup first round on Saturday. Meanwhile, York City must regroup quickly ahead of their Sky Bet League Two season opener against Bristol Rovers at the LNER Community Stadium on Saturday, August 15.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What was the final score between York City and Crawley Town?
- Crawley Town defeated York City 2-0 at the LNER Community Stadium.
- Who scored the goals in the match?
- Gianmarco Di Biase opened the scoring in the 24th minute, and Danilo Orsi added a second from the penalty spot in the 86th minute.
- Who do Crawley Town play next in the Carabao Cup?
- Crawley Town will travel to Vicarage Road to play Championship side Watford in the first round.
- When is York City's next league match?
- York City open their Sky Bet League Two campaign at home against Bristol Rovers on Saturday, August 15.