15 Points in Four Games: Why the New York Rangers Top Line Still Has a Defensive Flaw

The New York Rangers' top line of Mika Zibanejad, Alexis Lafrenière, and Gabe Perreault racked up 15 points on a four-game West Coast trip, yet underlying metrics show they still surrender more scoring chances than they create.

Published

Key points

  • Mika Zibanejad, Alexis Lafrenière, and Gabe Perreault combined for five goals and 10 assists over four West Coast games.
  • Despite the offensive surge, the Rangers top line allowed 25 scoring chances against while generating 17 on the trip.
  • Coach Mike Sullivan reunited the top line on November 5 after briefly inserting Pavel Dorofeyev to spark scoring.
  • New York entered its November 16 home game against Montreal at 12-8-1 after winning five of its previous six contests.
On this page

Across a four-game West Coast swing, the New York Rangers' top forward trio of Mika Zibanejad, Alexis Lafrenière, and Gabe Perreault exploded for five goals and 10 assists—yet they surrendered 25 scoring chances against while generating just 17. Entering their Monday night clash against the Montreal Canadiens at Madison Square Garden, the Blueshirts carried a 12-8-1 record backed by five wins in six games. Despite their recent offensive surge, analytics from MoneyPuck and Natural Stat Trick reveal that New York's premier line is still fighting to balance rush offense with defensive control under head coach Mike Sullivan.

Alexis Lafreniere celebrates a goal with Gabe Perreault and Mika Zibanejad
New York Rangers forwards Alexis Lafrenière, Gabe Perreault, and Mika Zibanejad celebrate in Vancouver — New York Post

The Result

The provided pre-game reports cover the buildup to Monday night's 7:30 p.m. ET regular-season matchup between the New York Rangers (12-8-1) and the Montreal Canadiens (12-4-4) at Madison Square Garden, broadcast on HBO MAX, truTV, TNT, SN+, and TVAS. Because both source dispatches were filed ahead of puck drop on November 16, 2026, a final score for the Canadiens-Rangers contest has not been recorded in the available reporting.

What is confirmed is the trajectory carrying New York into the game: the Rangers won five of their previous six contests following a grueling road trip through Seattle and Western Canada, capped by a Friday, November 13 victory over the Vancouver Canucks in which the top line executed a crisp tic-tac-toe goal off the rush.

How the Match Unfolded

Rather than a single game script, the Rangers' early 2026-27 season has unfolded in distinct tactical phases as head coach Mike Sullivan worked to unlock his top unit. From the opening day of training camp, New York aimed to recapture the late-season chemistry that made Zibanejad, Lafrenière, and Perreault their most productive trio a year ago.

Early results fell short of expectations. Before the home opener in early October, Sullivan noted that the unit had not been as impactful as anticipated, though the staff initially preached patience. By early November, however, Sullivan briefly broke up the trio, placing Pavel Dorofeyev alongside Zibanejad and Lafrenière to spark scoring before reuniting the original line mid-game on November 5 right before departing on their West Coast trip.

NHL matchup preview graphic for Canadiens at Rangers
Montreal Canadiens and New York Rangers prepare for their Madison Square Garden matchup — NHL.com

That November 5 reunion paid immediate dividends on the scoresheet. Over four games in Seattle and Western Canada, the line piled up 15 combined points, with four of their five goals coming at 5-on-5 strength. Still, Natural Stat Trick tracking showed that in three of those four road games, the line posted an expected goals-for percentage below 52 percent—the lowest mark among all Rangers forward lines during that stretch.

When we’re at our very best, we’re a checking team that has the ability to score, and when we value playing defense, we can create a lot of offense through our defense, and I think we’re a lot harder to play against.

— Mike Sullivan, New York Rangers Head Coach

Standout Performances

Individual turnarounds fueled the top line's recent statistical rebound, breaking prolonged early-season slumps for all three forwards ahead of the NHL.com matchup against Montreal:

  • Mika Zibanejad (Center): After managing only three goals across the Rangers' first 19 games, Zibanejad broke through on Wednesday during the road trip for his first multigoal performance since March.
  • Alexis Lafrenière (Wing): Following a hot start of nine goals in his first 13 games, Lafrenière endured a seven-game goal drought before snapping it off the rush against Vancouver on November 13.
  • Gabe Perreault (Wing): Perreault stabilized the right side by scoring three goals over his five games entering Monday's home date.

According to MoneyPuck data cited by the New York Post, the Zibanejad-Lafrenière-Perreault trio entered Monday ranked 22nd in the NHL in expected goals per 60 minutes among lines with at least 100 minutes together, while holding the league's 12th-best expected goals against per 60 minutes at 2.26.

What the Result Means

For a Rangers squad sitting at 12-8-1, the top line's two-way consistency carries direct implications for their standing in the Eastern Conference playoff race. While part of their 25-to-17 scoring-chance deficit on the road stems from routinely matching up against opponents' top-six forwards, Sullivan has emphasized that New York cannot trade defense for offense.

If Zibanejad, Lafrenière, and Perreault can sustain their 5-on-5 rush scoring while tightening their defensive zone coverage, they give New York a legitimate top-line anchor capable of driving possession against elite competition rather than relying purely on counterattacks.

What Comes Next

The immediate test comes on home ice at Madison Square Garden against a Montreal Canadiens lineup boasting a 12-4-4 record and a top line of Cole Caufield, Nick Suzuki, and Juraj Slafkovsky. Montreal arrives in New York dealing with a lengthy lower-body injury list that includes former Ranger Chris Kreider, alongside Josh Anderson, Mike Matheson, Samuel Montembeault, and Ivan Demidov—giving New York's reunited top trio an immediate opportunity to prove their two-way progress against a shorthanded division rival.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who plays on the New York Rangers top line in November 2026?

Center Mika Zibanejad skates between wings Alexis Lafrenière and Gabe Perreault. Head coach Mike Sullivan reunited the trio mid-game on November 5, 2026, after briefly testing Pavel Dorofeyev on the line.

How many points did the Rangers top line score on their West Coast road trip?

Zibanejad, Lafrenière, and Perreault combined for five goals—four at 5-on-5—and 10 assists across four games in Seattle and Western Canada.

Why are analytics critical of the Zibanejad-Lafrenière-Perreault line?

Despite scoring 15 points on the road trip, the line surrendered 25 scoring chances against while generating 17, posting an expected goals-for percentage below 52 percent in three of those four games.

Which Montreal Canadiens players were injured ahead of the November 16, 2026 game against the Rangers?

Montreal listed five players out with lower-body injuries: Chris Kreider, Josh Anderson, Mike Matheson, Samuel Montembeault, and Ivan Demidov.

People in this article