Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith strengthened his position as the 2026 Heisman Trophy favorite on Saturday, November 21, despite the Buckeyes losing 31-28 at Nebraska. Smith caught six passes for 165 yards and two touchdowns, keeping his individual campaign on track during a difficult season for Ohio State. FanDuel Sportsbook subsequently listed him at -360, well ahead of Miami quarterback Darian Mensah at +480. Meanwhile, Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker has slipped to +12500 after a disappointing stretch for the Cowboys.

What Happened
Smith delivered another standout performance in Nebraska, opening Ohio State's scoring with a 67-yard touchdown reception. Nebraska responded with 21 unanswered points, but Smith struck again before halftime, catching a 31-yard touchdown in the back of the end zone.
The Buckeyes ultimately lost by three points, extending a challenging campaign to 7-4. Yet Smith's production has remained remarkably consistent despite the absence of starting quarterback Julian Sayin, who suffered an undisclosed throwing-arm injury against Indiana on October 17.
Smith has now recorded 86 receptions, 1,482 receiving yards and 17 touchdowns. He has caught at least four passes for 68 yards in every game this season and has scored a touchdown in all but one contest.
His sustained production explains why his Heisman position has survived both quarterback disruption and Ohio State's struggles. The award race increasingly centers on whether another contender can overcome his statistical advantage.
The Facts Confirmed
The FanDuel odds reported by Bleacher Report after Saturday's 3:30 p.m. Eastern game window provide the clearest snapshot of the market:
- Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State WR: -360
- Darian Mensah, Miami QB: +480
- Devon Dampier, Utah QB: +1200
- Gio Lopez, Wake Forest QB: +2500
- CJ Carr, Notre Dame QB: +3500
- Gunner Stockton, Georgia QB: +3500
- Keelon Russell, Alabama QB: +6000
- Arch Manning, Texas QB: +12500
- Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State QB: +12500
- DeSean Bishop, Tennessee RB: +17500
- Bear Bachmeier, BYU QB: +25000
- Nate Sheppard, Duke RB: +40000

These prices show how sharply the market separates Smith from the field. Mensah is the closest challenger, while Dampier occupies third place. The remaining contenders face substantially longer odds.
Impact on the Team or Competition
Ohio State's defeat complicates the traditional relationship between team success and individual awards. Bleacher Report expects the Buckeyes to miss the College Football Playoff following their 7-4 season, but Smith continues producing numbers that distinguish him from players on stronger teams.
Mensah offers the clearest alternative. Miami was listed seventh in the College Football Playoff standings in Bleacher Report's account, while its quarterback had accumulated 3,076 passing yards and 29 touchdowns. NCAA.com's ranking of Heisman contenders also credited Mensah with the FBS lead in completion percentage and just two interceptions.
Utah quarterback Devon Dampier has another compelling case. His 22 passing touchdowns and nine rushing scores have helped keep Utah undefeated, and he produced four total touchdowns in each of his previous two games against ranked opponents.
Oklahoma State's Mestemaker illustrates the opposite trajectory. Despite entering Saturday with an FBS-leading 3,239 passing yards and 30 touchdowns, he has suffered from the Cowboys losing three of their previous five games. Against Texas Tech, he threw for 277 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions in a 52-27 defeat.
The contrast is significant: Smith has maintained his standing despite team losses, while Mestemaker's individual passing totals have not prevented his odds from deteriorating.
How the Club or Athlete Responded
The supplied reports contain no direct public statement from Smith, Sayin or Ohio State's coaching staff addressing the latest Heisman odds. Smith's response on the field, however, has been measurable: two touchdowns and 165 yards against Nebraska despite the continued absence of his starting quarterback.
NCAA.com's earlier contender assessment placed Smith first, followed by Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr and Miami's Mensah. Its ranking also highlighted Carr's three first-half touchdown passes against Miami and Notre Dame's 9-1 record at that stage.
Those assessments reflect different measures of candidacy. Sportsbook prices indicate the market's current expectations, while editorial rankings consider performances, team achievements and the remaining schedule. Neither determines the eventual vote.
What Happens Next
Smith has one regular-season opportunity remaining in the supplied schedule: Ohio State faces Michigan next Saturday at noon Eastern. Another productive outing would strengthen an already commanding statistical résumé.
Mensah and Dampier have opportunities to make their own cases through their teams' postseason ambitions. Notre Dame's Carr, Georgia's Stockton and Wake Forest's Lopez also remain among the candidates identified by NCAA.com.
There is a historical obstacle for Smith: quarterbacks have dominated recent Heisman voting. NCAA.com reports that quarterbacks won 21 of the previous 26 awards. Smith is attempting to overcome that positional pattern while playing for a team whose record has fallen short of expectations.
The ceremony is approximately three weeks away according to NCAA.com's November contender report. The supplied sources do not provide an exact ceremony date or a confirmed finalist announcement schedule.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is favored to win the 2026 Heisman Trophy?
Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith leads the FanDuel market at -360 following his 165-yard, two-touchdown performance against Nebraska.
What are Jeremiah Smith's Heisman odds?
Smith is listed at -360, corresponding to an implied probability of approximately 78.26% before sportsbook margin.
Who is second in the Heisman odds?
Miami quarterback Darian Mensah is second at +480, followed by Utah quarterback Devon Dampier at +1200.
Why did Drew Mestemaker fall in the Heisman race?
Oklahoma State lost three of its previous five games, and Mestemaker threw two interceptions during a 52-27 defeat against Texas Tech. His listed odds are +12500.
How many touchdowns does Jeremiah Smith have?
Smith has 17 receiving touchdowns alongside 86 catches and 1,482 receiving yards through 11 games.
When does Ohio State play Michigan?
The Buckeyes are scheduled to face Michigan next Saturday at noon Eastern, according to Bleacher Report's November 22 coverage.