Police officers in Northern Ireland spent the equivalent of more than 18,482 working days attending court during 2024-25, at an estimated cost exceeding £4 million, despite many never being called to testify. A criminal justice inspection has exposed widespread disruption to witnesses, forensic scientists and frontline policing. In a review of 30 prosecution cases, just 34% of hearings proceeded as scheduled. Inspectors are demanding changes to how witnesses are summoned, notified and allowed to give evidence.

What Was Decided
Criminal Justice Inspection Northern Ireland (CJI) has published findings calling for substantial reform of witness attendance arrangements in criminal courts. This is an inspection report rather than a judicial ruling: no court has issued a new verdict, sentence or injunction as part of the findings.
The central recommendation is that the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) and the Public Prosecution Service (PPS) establish an effective process to inform police operational planners when officers are no longer needed at hearings.
Acting Chief Inspector James Corrigan said the notification system should be introduced within six months. Inspectors also want better management of police attendance, greater use of digital witness summonses and more opportunities to give evidence remotely.
The findings, detailed by Irish Legal News, identify repeated failures to coordinate hearings and witnesses efficiently.
The Case Background
The inspection examined how witnesses are required to attend criminal proceedings and whether that attendance results in evidence being heard.
Inspectors reviewed 30 prosecution cases and surveyed police officers, forensic scientists and members of the public. Their findings revealed a striking gap between the number of people required to attend and those actually giving evidence.
- 34% of hearings in the reviewed cases proceeded as planned.
- 60% of responding police officers and forensic scientists said they rarely gave evidence in court.
- 16% of those professional respondents said they had never given evidence.
- 55% of surveyed public witnesses said they did not give evidence.
Late guilty pleas, evidence being agreed shortly before hearings, cases not being ready and the unavailability of witnesses or legal representatives all contributed to disrupted proceedings.
Corrigan described delays extending from initial investigations through prosecution decisions and into court adjournments. That sequence means inefficiency cannot be attributed solely to what happens inside a courtroom.

What the Ruling Means
Although the report does not establish a new legal precedent, its recommendations could change the practical experience of criminal proceedings for police, witnesses and victims.
The financial implications are substantial. CJI calculated that police court attendance during 2024-25 represented more than 18,482 average working days, costing over £4 million using the relevant pay scales.
That figure does not include the full expense of replacing officers on operational shifts, prosecution staff attending ineffective hearings, defence witnesses or specialist experts.
For policing, reducing unnecessary attendance could release officers for frontline duties. For members of the public, earlier cancellation notices could prevent avoidable travel, childcare arrangements and time away from employment.
There is also a human cost. Witnesses may prepare emotionally for difficult testimony, only to discover shortly before proceedings that their attendance is unnecessary.
Corrigan warned that repeated disruption can damage confidence in the justice system. The inspection therefore connects administrative inefficiency with the experience of people whose evidence is essential to criminal cases.
Reactions and Next Steps
The PSNI said it was considering the inspection findings. Assistant Chief Constable Anthony McNally acknowledged that officers must be available to give evidence while recognising the operational consequences of unnecessary appearances.
However, unnecessary or late-cancelled court attendances can affect our ability to deploy officers to front-line and other operational duties.
Janice Bunting, chief executive of Victim Support NI, highlighted the distress experienced by witnesses whose cases are cancelled or adjourned at short notice.
Her organisation supports witnesses attending Crown and magistrates' courts. She explained that preparing to testify can involve arranging family responsibilities, taking leave from work and managing considerable anxiety.
The BBC's reporting on the inspection also highlighted Corrigan's proposal for greater use of remote evidence centres, particularly for vulnerable witnesses who may find the courtroom intimidating.
What Happens Next
The immediate priority is the recommended six-month timetable for the PSNI and PPS to develop and implement a reliable cancellation-notification process.
Inspectors also want criminal justice organisations to consider electronic witness summonses and remote testimony from suitable locations, including police stations.
These proposals would allow some officers to remain closer to operational duties until their evidence is required, while potentially making proceedings less stressful for vulnerable witnesses.
The inspection does not announce a binding implementation order or confirm that the proposed digital systems have been introduced. The PSNI's consideration of the recommendations is the response reported so far.
The wider challenge is coordinating investigations, prosecution decisions and court scheduling so witnesses are summoned when their evidence is genuinely needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does police court attendance cost in Northern Ireland?
Inspectors estimated that PSNI officer attendance during 2024-25 cost more than £4 million, equivalent to over 18,482 average working days. Additional staffing and witness costs were excluded.
Why are witnesses attending court without giving evidence?
Reasons include late guilty pleas, evidence being agreed shortly before hearings, unprepared cases and unavailable legal representatives or witnesses.
What percentage of court hearings went ahead as planned?
Only 34% of hearings proceeded as scheduled in the 30 prosecution cases examined by Criminal Justice Inspection Northern Ireland.
When must police improve court attendance notifications?
Acting Chief Inspector James Corrigan recommended that the PSNI and PPS implement an effective notification process within six months of the report.
Can witnesses give evidence remotely in Northern Ireland?
The inspection called for greater use of remote evidence centres and suggested that more police officers could testify from police stations where appropriate.