7 tries that exposed England in South Africa's 45-21 rout

South Africa scored seven tries in a 45-21 Nations Championship win that exposed England's discipline problems and raised the stakes before Fiji.

South Africa 45-21 England: 7 tries expose problems
Last UpdateJul 5, 2026, 11:53:30 AM
ago
📢Advertisement

7 tries that exposed England in South Africa's 45-21 rout

Ellis Park was barely settled before England were being driven backwards. South Africa scored three tries inside the opening 12 minutes, survived an unlikely fightback before half-time and then pulled away for a 45-21 victory in Johannesburg. The seven-try defeat leaves Steve Borthwick's side on a five-match losing streak and turns their next two fixtures against Fiji and Argentina into sharper tests of where this team really stands.

South Africa and England players contest the Nations Championship match at Ellis Park
South Africa beat England 45-21 in Johannesburg — BBC

How Events Unfolded

South Africa struck first through Thomas du Toit inside three minutes. Cheslin Kolbe followed after Ox Nche's break opened England up, then Kurt-Lee Arendse crossed to make it 17-0 after 12 minutes. The pace, power and cohesion of the hosts left England chasing the match almost immediately.

England did not disappear. Ellis Genge powered over from a quick tap penalty, while George Martin scored just before the interval after Fin Smith's 50:22 helped create the position. Suddenly, an England side that had looked overwhelmed went into half-time only 17-14 behind.

The comeback did not survive the restart. Grant Williams sniped through after a long spell of England goal-line defence, and Jesse Kriel added another try as South Africa rebuilt control. Alex Coles later crossed for England, but yellow cards for Tommy Freeman and Guy Pepper reduced the visitors to 13 men.

Malcolm Marx and Ben-Jason Dixon finished the job with late scores, completing a seven-try win. The full scoring detail and line-ups are available in the BBC match report.

Under the Surface

The scoreline was not simply about South Africa's size. Their kicking game repeatedly put England's backfield under pressure, while Damian Willemse and the Springbok wings controlled the aerial contest. England had been forced into a late reshuffle after George Furbank underwent surgery for appendicitis, leaving Marcus Smith at full-back.

South Africa also had disruption to absorb. Siya Kolisi and Eben Etzebeth withdrew before kick-off, joining an already significant injury list, yet the hosts still produced a dominant opening and a clinical second half. That depth is one reason the double reigning world champions could recover quickly when England briefly closed the gap.

England players under pressure during the 45-21 defeat by South Africa
England fought back before South Africa pulled clear after the break — Sky Sports

Discipline was the other decisive thread. England conceded 13 penalties, including nine after the interval, and their two late yellow cards removed any realistic chance of another recovery. The defeat also extended a longer pattern: England have received at least one yellow card in eight consecutive games.

Voices & Opinions

Borthwick accepted that South Africa had controlled a key part of the contest, particularly the aerial game. His comments matter because pressure on the England head coach had already increased after a Six Nations campaign featuring four defeats in five matches.

We were playing against the best team in the world and it doesn't get much tougher than that.

Steve Borthwick, England head coach

Captain Jamie George focused on the fight England showed after falling 17 points behind, but also on the periods when the match escaped them.

The overriding messages after were we showed a lot of fight and character to stay in the game, and then we let it slip at times.

Jamie George, England captain

Former England fly-half Paul Grayson was more direct on BBC Radio 5 Live's assessment: England failed to establish enough control after the break and their attack became fragmented.

Putting It in Perspective

This was England's fourth successive defeat by South Africa and their fifth loss in a row overall. Losing away to the world champions is not, by itself, a verdict on Borthwick's future. The problem is what the wider sequence says about England's discipline, consistency and ability to stay competitive once a match turns against them.

South Africa and England in action during their Nations Championship opener
England briefly reduced the gap to three points before South Africa took over — The Guardian

There were useful signs. Genge, Martin and Coles all scored, Fin Smith recovered from a difficult opening, and England found enough attacking moments to threaten the best team in the sport. Yet those flashes were cancelled out by penalties, poor control of the aerial battle and a late collapse while down to 13 players.

For supporters in Britain, that makes the next match more than a routine stop in a new tournament. England's response in Liverpool will show whether Johannesburg becomes a hard lesson against an elite opponent or another step in a worsening run.

Looking Ahead

England return home to face Fiji at Hill Dickinson Stadium in Liverpool on 11 July. They then travel to face Argentina on 18 July.

South Africa's next confirmed fixture is against Scotland in Pretoria on 11 July. For England, victories in the next two matches would not erase a 45-21 defeat, but they would provide evidence that the side can correct the discipline and control problems identified in Johannesburg.

FAQ

What was the South Africa v England rugby result?

South Africa beat England 45-21 at Ellis Park in Johannesburg.

How many tries did South Africa score against England?

The Springboks scored seven tries through Thomas du Toit, Cheslin Kolbe, Kurt-Lee Arendse, Grant Williams, Jesse Kriel, Malcolm Marx and Ben-Jason Dixon.

Who scored England's tries?

Ellis Genge, George Martin and Alex Coles scored England's three tries.

Why did England finish with 13 players?

Tommy Freeman and Guy Pepper were both shown yellow cards late in the second half.

Who do England play next?

England face Fiji in Liverpool on 11 July, followed by Argentina on 18 July.

How long is England's losing streak?

The defeat by South Africa was England's fifth consecutive loss.

Jody Nageeb profile photo

Written by

Jody Nageeb

Senior Editor

Expert in business, sports, and transportation trends.

AuthorAiDisclosure

LearnAboutOurMethodology
BusinessFinanceSportsAutomotive

📚Resources

Sources and references cited in this article.