This page is available in English

Why Are Former Ambassadors Warning Canada Against Relying on Europe for Trade?

Former Canadian ambassadors to the U.S. Derek Burney and David MacNaughton told MPs that EU red tape makes Europe a poor substitute for American trade, urging Ottawa to focus on Asian markets and domestic resource export infrastructure.

게시됨

핵심 요약

  • Former ambassadors Derek Burney and David MacNaughton warned MPs that EU regulatory barriers slow Canadian export diversification.
  • Both diplomats urged Ottawa to prioritize faster-growing Asian markets seeking Canadian LNG, oil, and critical minerals.
  • Canada supplies just 1 per cent of EU imports, even as U.S. tariffs heavily expose manufacturing towns in Ontario and Quebec.
  • Prime Minister Mark Carney recently secured free trade deals with ASEAN nations and the Philippines during his trip to Asia.
이 페이지의 내용

With U.S. tariffs squeezing Canadian manufacturing towns and reshaping supply chains across the country, Ottawa's strategy to reduce its reliance on American buyers has become a pressing economic issue for Canadian workers and businesses. On Monday, Nov. 16, two former Canadian ambassadors to the United States, Derek Burney and David MacNaughton, warned lawmakers on the House of Commons foreign affairs committee that Canada is spending too much effort trying to expand trade with Europe. Instead, both diplomats argued that Canada's fractured relationship with Washington requires an aggressive pivot toward fast-growing Asian markets, backed by domestic infrastructure capable of shipping natural resources abroad.

Former Canadian diplomats testifying on Canada-U.S. trade strategy
Former ambassadors Derek Burney and David MacNaughton testified before the House of Commons foreign affairs committee — Yahoo News Canada

What Is Being Proposed

Rather than treating Europe as the primary alternative to the American market, Burney and MacNaughton urged the federal government to prioritize trade expansion across Asia. Their testimony focused on redirecting Canada's trade diversification strategy during an ongoing trade war with the United States, arguing that Asia offers far greater commercial upside than the European Union.

Burney specifically pointed to recent diplomatic momentum in the region, welcoming a free trade agreement reached with ASEAN countries during Prime Minister Mark Carney's international trip through Asia this week, alongside a separate trade deal reached with the Philippines. As Carney pursues Asian trade talks to protect domestic industries, the former diplomats emphasized that signing deals is only the first step.

What It Would Change

Shifting Canada's trade priority from Europe to Asia would require major changes in domestic infrastructure and export focus. According to Burney, Asian economies are primarily interested in Canadian natural resources—specifically liquefied natural gas (LNG), oil, and critical minerals—rather than the regulatory-heavy European market.

To capture that demand, Burney argued Canada must build the domestic facilities needed to get those resources to tidewater and ship them overseas. At the same time, data from an interactive tariff vulnerability map developed by the University of Toronto's School of Cities shows why the stakes are high at home: extractive industries tied to critical minerals across northern Ontario, northern Manitoba, and northern Saskatchewan have remained relatively insulated from U.S. tariffs, whereas manufacturing hubs in Ontario and aluminum-producing regions in Quebec like Chicoutimi and Dolbeau-Mistassini face heavy exposure.

Former Canadian ambassador David MacNaughton speaking at the House foreign affairs committee
Former ambassador David MacNaughton warned MPs about European regulatory barriers — The Hill Times
CETA (Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement)
The bilateral trade deal between Canada and the European Union, which Burney noted took nine years for European authorities to approve.
ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations)
A regional bloc of Southeast Asian nations with which Canada reached a free trade agreement during Prime Minister Mark Carney's trip to Asia.
CUSMA (Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement)
The North American trade pact whose compliance rules and U.S. export intensity heavily influence how exposed Canadian industrial regions are to American tariffs.

Who Supports and Who Opposes It

Both Burney and MacNaughton, who served as Canada's ambassador to Washington from 2016 to 2019, agreed that European bureaucracy and sluggish economic conditions make the bloc a poor substitute for U.S. trade. Burney told MPs that Ottawa may be wasting too much time on Europe, pointing out that EU approval of CETA dragged on for nine years.

The bureaucracy of the European Union would make the bureaucracy in Canada look like a pygmy by comparison, and the regulatory regime in the EU is not exactly welcome or attractive to many businesses who want to get deals done in a pragmatic way,

— Derek Burney, Former Canadian Ambassador to the United States

MacNaughton backed that assessment, telling the committee that European economies are struggling and that fragmented regulatory systems across member states prevent Canadian exporters from quickly redirecting shipments. Both diplomats also expressed deep pessimism about reaching a reliable trade settlement with Washington, with Burney stating he does not see how Canada can reach a satisfactory negotiation with a U.S. leader who disregards international trade norms and existing agreements, and MacNaughton noting the U.S. president faces virtually no internal pushback from his advisors.

By contrast, the federal government has continued pursuing deeper European ties alongside its Asian outreach. In May, Canada and Germany signed a long-term deal to supply LNG from the proposed Ksi Lisims LNG project on British Columbia's northern coast, and last month Ottawa and the EU launched an Alliance for the Future to tackle trade irritants. Meanwhile, an October report from TD Bank found that while Canada currently supplies just 1 per cent of EU goods and services imports, demand for nearly $60 billion in additional Canadian exports could materialize under the right conditions.

Where Things Stand

The debate is playing out in Parliament while Canadian businesses navigate worsening tariff vulnerabilities mapped by researchers led by Karen Chapple and Tara Vinodrai at the University of Toronto. Their community-level tariff impact map, built using data from Statistics Canada, the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, and U.S. federal agencies, illustrates how layered U.S. tariffs on steel, dairy, alcohol, aluminum, and manufacturing ripple outward from industrial plants into surrounding rural communities where workers live.

Burney and MacNaughton both acknowledged that seeking new opportunities in Europe has value in reducing Canada's vulnerability to U.S. trade shocks, even as they insisted Asia should command far greater urgency from policymakers.

What Happens Next

Prime Minister Mark Carney's ongoing diplomatic tour in Asia is expected to remain a central test of whether Canada can convert new agreements with ASEAN and the Philippines into concrete export growth. For Ottawa, the next phase involves deciding how aggressively to back domestic energy and mineral export infrastructure—such as West Coast LNG facilities—while balancing existing European commitments and shielding vulnerable manufacturing communities in Ontario and Quebec from prolonged U.S. tariff pressure.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did former ambassadors say Canada is wasting time on Europe?

Former ambassadors Derek Burney and David MacNaughton told a House of Commons committee that the European Union's complex regulatory regimes, slow approval processes—such as taking nine years to approve CETA—and sluggish economies make it difficult for Canadian businesses to quickly expand exports there.

Which markets do the former ambassadors say Canada should focus on instead?

Both diplomats urged Ottawa to focus more aggressively on Asian markets, citing stronger economic growth and high demand for Canadian natural resources like liquefied natural gas (LNG), oil, and critical minerals.

How much does Canada currently export to the European Union?

According to an October report by TD Bank cited in coverage of the testimony, Canada currently supplies just 1 per cent of the European Union's goods and services imports, though the report estimated potential demand for nearly $60 billion in additional Canadian exports under certain conditions.

Which parts of Canada are most vulnerable to U.S. tariffs?

Research from the University of Toronto's School of Cities shows that manufacturing-heavy regions in Ontario—affected by steel, dairy, alcohol, and industrial tariffs—and aluminum-producing areas in Quebec face the highest exposure, whereas northern critical mineral mining regions are less vulnerable.

What recent trade deals has Canada reached in Asia?

During Prime Minister Mark Carney's international trip through Asia, Canada reached a free trade agreement with ASEAN countries as well as a trade agreement with the Philippines.

출처

  1. Former ambassador says Canada is ‘wasting too much time’ on EuropeYahoo News Canada2026년 11월 17일
  2. How did tariffs hit your town? This interactive map zooms in for the answerGuelph News2026년 11월 17일

이 기사 속 인물